I think it would be scary too! My dad's friend tried an experiment on his friends to see what they would do in a horrific experience. They were sitting in front of their TV watching a horror movie, and when it came to a part where a person was dragged away, my dad's friend dragged away a person watching the movie. He would tell the friend to be quiet and then put ketchup on his or her chest. And he would keep going.
Throughout the whole thing, the friends did what "dumb" people in horror movies would do. They freaked out and split up, causing another person to be carried off. Before doing this experiment, of course, he told the neighbors not to call the police. So the neighbors just sat on the lawn, eating popcorn, and hearing screams and shrieks from the house.